PlanChange could say what a move would cost and whether it was allowed, and
that was all it could do. Billing::purchase() wrote an upgrade order and
nothing ever consumed it: same snapshot, same machine, same quota. A customer
could pay for a bigger package and receive nothing.
ApplyPlanChange is now the single place a change lands — it moves the contract
onto the target's current version, writes one register row, settles the custom
domain, and starts a run that resizes the machine. Applying the same order
twice is a no-op, enforced by a unique event key rather than by a check two
callers could both pass.
Two things a plan change must not do, and now does not. A disk is never shrunk
— Proxmox cannot, so the QUOTA shrinks instead, which is what was sold anyway.
And a live machine is never rebooted as a side effect: cores and RAM are
written, and where they need a restart the instance says so where an operator
and the customer can both see it.
The storage allowance also joins the build pipeline. ApplyStorageQuota was
written for plan changes and ran only there, so a brand-new customer still got
no quota at all — quota_gb reached the instance row and stopped, and every
package delivered the whole disk. The test guarding that pipeline only counted
its steps, which is how a list missing the one step that makes a package's
storage real stayed green for its whole life. It now names the step.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A verified custom domain was reported as the customer's address by
Instance::address(), by the portal and by the credentials mail while
nothing on the platform routed it: the Traefik router's rule was
hard-coded to {subdomain}.{zone}. The address a customer was handed
answered nothing, and a withdrawn domain stayed in Nextcloud's
trusted_domains forever, because the only thing that ever wrote either
was the initial provisioning run.
- TraefikWriter::write() takes a LIST of hostnames under one stable
router name — the platform address always, the verified domain as
well when there is one. One file per instance, so a withdrawal is a
rewrite rather than a second thing somebody has to remember.
- ConfigureDnsAndTls records the custom domain's certificate instead of
waiting on it: it depends on an A record in the customer's own zone,
which may never appear, and must never fail a run. The platform
address keeps its 840s deadline. instances.domain_cert_ok tells
"proven" apart from "answering", and the portal now says which.
- ConfigureNextcloud deletes trusted_domains 2 when there is no verified
domain, so a withdrawn one stops being trusted.
- New `address` pipeline (those two steps) plus ReapplyInstanceAddress,
which starts one against the order and refuses to start a second while
any run is in flight. The route is rewritten when the hostname list
differs from what the router carries — not on route_written, which
would short-circuit exactly the case a re-apply exists for.
- Triggered where the address changes: verification flipping either way
in clupilot:verify-domains, the customer's own domain page, and
CustomDomainAccess::deactivate() on a package downgrade.
- A maintenance run no longer condemns its subject: an address run that
failed used to mark the order failed and release the live instance
with it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A grant is an order without money, not a second code path: GrantSubscription
and GrantAddon create the same Order/Subscription/SubscriptionAddon rows a
paid purchase does, with stripe_subscription_id left null and price_cents set
to whatever the customer actually pays. OpenSubscription and BookAddon gained
an optional overrides parameter so the price and provenance (who granted it,
when, a note, an optional end date, and the catalogue price for legibility)
land on the same snapshot every real purchase goes through, not a duplicate.
New customers.grant_plan capability, Owner-only like secrets.manage — giving
away service is exactly the kind of blast radius that precedent reserves for
the Owner.
A Product per plan family and a Price per priced row of a published version,
plus the four subscribed webhook events that were arriving and being ignored.
`stripe:sync-catalogue` mirrors the catalogue. Idempotent twice over: a stored
id is skipped, and each call carries an idempotency key derived from our own
row, so a crash between Stripe creating a Price and us recording its id gives
back the same object rather than a second one. That matters more here than
usual — a Stripe Price cannot be edited or deleted, so a duplicate is
permanent. Drafts are not synced at all: a version that has promised nothing
has no business in a price list. --dry-run shows what would be created.
The webhook now handles invoice.paid, invoice.payment_failed,
customer.subscription.updated and customer.subscription.deleted. It never
re-derives an amount: the invoice is the authority for what was charged, and
recomputing it from our catalogue would produce a second, disagreeing answer.
A failed payment is recorded and nothing else — Stripe runs the dunning
schedule, and cutting a customer off on the first failure would punish an
expired card as though it were a refusal to pay.
Only a cycle renewal moves the term on. Stripe also sends paid invoices for
prorations and manual charges, and the checkout's own invoice — which is
already in the register as the purchase, and would otherwise double every
customer's first payment.
Stripe does not guarantee delivery order, which is the source of most of the
care here:
- state changes are judged and written in one transaction with the row held,
so two deliveries cannot both pass a check made on a stale copy;
- an older event never overwrites a newer one, with a rank breaking ties
between events sharing a second — their timestamps have one-second
resolution, and a failed attempt and its successful retry routinely do;
- a term is never shortened, and an ended contract is never revived;
- an event for a contract that does not exist yet is HELD and replayed the
moment it appears, rather than acknowledged and forgotten. A cancellation
dropped that way would leave us serving someone who had already left. Held
rows that never match are pruned after a week.
Register entries are keyed by what they are about — the invoice, the attempt,
the subscription — with a unique index doing the work, because a check two
concurrent deliveries can both pass is not idempotency.
PlanChange is now documented as the preview shown before someone confirms, not
the invoice: Stripe's proration accounts for tax, existing credit and the exact
second the change lands, and ours cannot.
Not run against the live account — `stripe:sync-catalogue` creates objects that
cannot be deleted, so that is the owner's call. The dry run lists 12.
457 tests green. Codex review clean after seven rounds.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Plans lived in config/provisioning.php, where the owner cannot reach them and
where a plan has no history. They now live in plan_families / plan_versions /
plan_prices — a name that never moves, what the plan WAS at a point in time,
and a price per version and term with its own Stripe Price id.
- Availability is computed on every read (available_from <= now < until,
half-open, UTC) plus a per-family sales kill switch. Nothing schedules a plan
into or out of sale: a job that fails to run is a plan that silently
misbehaves.
- Overlaps crash rather than resolve. currentVersion() uses sole(), and
scheduling takes a lock on the family and rejects an overlapping window —
two versions on sale at once would decide a customer's price by row order.
- A version is frozen from publication, not from first sale, and so is its
price: a checkout is not instant, and an amount edited between the session
opening and the webhook landing would contract someone at a price they were
never quoted. Repricing publishes a new version, as Stripe requires anyway.
- Neither a published version, its price, nor a family with customers can be
deleted, and a family key cannot be renamed. All of those would null the
provenance off existing contracts.
- Subscriptions and orders record plan_version_id. A historical reference
resolved by plan NAME hands back today's terms, which is the split-brain one
level up. A checkout that carried its version is honoured even after the
window closes — they paid for what they were shown.
Switched atomically and failing closed: config('provisioning.plans') and
plan_features are gone, and nothing falls back to them. A fallback would
resurrect a plan the owner had just switched off. The seed lives in the
migration, and PlanCatalogueTest pins what the config catalogue sold as the
shadow comparison. `php artisan plans:check` reports overlaps, gaps and
missing prices before a customer finds them.
Contract-backed displays, which were reading the live catalogue:
seat limits, the cloud card, the plan card, and admin MRR — the last three now
divide a yearly contract down via Subscription::monthlyPriceCents(), since all
three label the figure per month.
Two recovery gaps closed along the way: the order now commits before the
contract is opened (so a contract failure can never erase the record of a
payment), a Stripe retry repairs a missing contract and restarts a run stranded
with no_subscription, and TickProvisioning sweeps runs left pending by a crash
rather than only running/waiting ones.
402 tests green. Codex review clean after thirteen rounds. Verified in the
browser: portal, billing and console render unchanged off the new catalogue.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The pipeline re-resolved config('provisioning.plans') by order.plan, so the
subscription snapshot protected a customer's price but not their machine:
shrinking a plan resized an existing customer's VM on its next run. Nothing
created a subscription either, so closing this meant opening the contract at
purchase and pointing provisioning at it.
- OpenSubscription freezes the catalogue onto a subscription when a checkout
is paid; StartCustomerProvisioning calls it inside the order transaction.
- CustomerStep::plan() reads the frozen snapshot. ValidateOrder and
ReserveResources fail closed with no_subscription rather than falling back
to the catalogue, which is the bug itself.
- template_vmid joins the snapshot so a re-clone cannot pick up a blueprint
published after the sale. Deliberately outside FROZEN: it is how we build
the machine, not a term the customer is owed, and a dead template must be
replaceable without cancelling a contract.
- TrafficMeter reads the allowance off the contract too — cutting a plan's
traffic was otherwise enough to start throttling someone who bought more.
- The migration backfills contracts for orders that already bought something,
reconstructed from what was actually delivered where an instance exists,
and adopts an existing order-less contract instead of opening a second.
Orders paid in a currency the catalogue cannot price get none, matching the
checkout path.
price_cents stays the catalogue's NET price, which is what PlanChange
prorates against — not Order::amount_cents, which holds Stripe's GROSS total.
Reconciling the two belongs to the proof register and Stripe (phases 4/5).
Also pins STRIPE_WEBHOOK_SECRET blank in phpunit.xml: the operator's real
secret was reaching the suite from .env and rejecting every unsigned test
payload, which is why 7 webhook tests failed before any of this.
Verified in the browser: with team traffic cut from 3000 to 500 GB in the
catalogue, the customer's portal still shows 3 TB.
373 tests green. Codex review clean after three rounds.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Codex was right that this could misstate real charges: an EU business with a
VAT ID registered in another country is billed under reverse charge, and we
were adding 20 % Austrian VAT to their total anyway. TaxTreatment resolves it
from the customer's VAT ID, and the whole page — cart, plan cards, add-on
cards — now states one treatment instead of contradicting itself.
Explicitly NOT handled: cross-border sales to private individuals, which are
taxed at the buyer's national rate under OSS. That needs a maintained rate
table and a tax adviser, not a guess, so those fall back to the domestic rate —
over-collecting rather than under-collecting.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two contradicting plan upgrades sat in the cart at 799 and 399 € — no checkout
could resolve which one the customer meant. Choosing another now replaces the
pending one and says so; add-ons still stack, because buying 200 GB as two packs
is a sensible thing to want.
Every price now states net or gross and how often. The cart shows net per line
with "pro Monat" or "einmalig", then subtotal, VAT and gross — and separates
the monthly recurring amount from a one-off traffic top-up sharing the same
cart, because those are two different commitments. The rate is configurable
(CLUPILOT_TAX_PERCENT, 20 % default) since it follows the seller's country.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
"5 purchases pending" told nobody what they had ordered and offered no way to
change their mind. The billing page now lists each pending purchase by name,
what it costs, when it was added, and the total — with a remove button per row
behind a confirmation, like every other destructive action in the console.
The wording lives on the Order model rather than in the view, so the cart, the
invoice list and any later confirmation mail cannot each invent their own name
for the same row. Removal is scoped to the customer's own still-pending orders,
checked in the modal itself: modals are reachable without the page's guards.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Failed run releases the instance (status=failed) so its quota stops counting
against host capacity.
- CompleteProvisioning activates instance+order only AFTER onboarding tasks +
credential delivery succeed.
- ConfigureNetwork polls until the guest has an address (no wrong Traefik route).
- customers.email unique + race-safe customer resolution in the intake action.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
nexxo